Dolphins attempting to trade for Vick - Stereokiller Message Boards

Joe Boccuto

programmatic
25,745 Posts
31/M/PA

(20)

October 1 2009 3:22 PM QuickQuote

Quote

Originally posted by:Wes Mantooth

I agree that McNabb is more talented/seasoned but I'll be damned if it doesn't seem like Kolb is more suited to their offensive gameplan. could just be me though.

it's the other way around. the gameplan was suited to kolb.

same thing happened with garcia 2 years ago.

how many screen passes did you see with kolb? how about long balls? how many wildcats did we see with mcnabb?

the gameplan for both kolb starts was clearly designed for easier plays with more wildcat than usual to help take pressure off of kolb.

it also has to do with the fact that the Oline is not even close to what they envisioned in the offseason, so things had to be adjusted.

with mcnabb it's a much more quick-strike deal. the kolb td to jackson this week was a fluke in that it was not designed to be a long play, desean is just that good.

Now, which style of offense one prefers is an entirely different matter.

Joe Boccuto

programmatic
25,745 Posts
31/M/PA

(20)

October 1 2009 3:24 PM QuickQuote

Quote

Originally posted by:fight2live

I wonder what the Eagles would get back for Vick. Probably a couple late round picks that big red will waste anyway

for a QB that will be starting on whatever eam trades for him (otherwise why trade for him at all), and for taking the PR hit and all that came with it, I'd be amazed if the Eagles took less than a 3rd in return. Otherwise just keep him. Cheap salary.

tom.

^__^
60,179 Posts
29/M/PA

(4)

October 1 2009 3:26 PM QuickQuote

Quote

Originally posted by: Wes Mantooth

I agree that McNabb is more talented/seasoned but I'll be damned if it doesn't seem like Kolb is more suited to their offensive gameplan. could just be me though.

definitely just you.

ass nipples

old dancing boy
31,879 Posts
28/M/PA

(7)

October 1 2009 3:27 PM QuickQuote

Quote

Originally posted by:cbrickhouse

i vastly underestimated kolb but he is nowhere near as good as mcnabb

VVes 570

m.t.f.u.
25,179 Posts
25/M/PA

(23)

October 1 2009 3:36 PM QuickQuote

Quote

Originally posted by:tom.

Originally posted by: Wes Mantooth

I agree that McNabb is more talented/seasoned but I'll be damned if it doesn't seem like Kolb is more suited to their offensive gameplan. could just be me though.

definitely just you.

I don't think it is and it's not like I'm the only person who thinks these things
and lately before the heat comes, I get it. you're Eagles fans, you have faith/love McNabb and there is nothing wrong with that.

tom.

^__^
60,179 Posts
29/M/PA

(4)

October 1 2009 3:44 PM QuickQuote

Quote

kolb has 1 win and 1 loss.
he beat the chiefs.
he beats the ravens and maybe i'll think he is something.

VVes 570

m.t.f.u.
25,179 Posts
25/M/PA

(23)

October 1 2009 3:46 PM QuickQuote

Quote

his qb rating and completion percentages are key here though
two 300 yard games ain't nothing to be ashamed of. and
even mentioned earlier that this is nothing but a prediction of how good Kolb is/could be.

fight2live

doe dubbla
18,995 Posts
33/M/PA

(12)

October 1 2009 3:49 PM QuickQuote

Quote

Originally posted by:Wes Mantooth

this is nothing but a prediction of how good Kolb is against shitty defenses

buck rogers

JIMMY f'n ROLLINS
2,470 Posts
34/M/PA

(9)

October 2 2009 12:52 AM QuickQuote

Quote

Originally posted by: tom.

Originally posted by: BroadStreetBully

Originally posted by:cbrickhouse

i support this trade.

just so i don't have to hear the dog lovers whine about him not being dead

WREN

Wolfman
46,299 Posts
30/M/PA

(19)

October 2 2009 8:51 AM QuickQuote

Quote

He'd be a benefit of the team but at the same time i don't really want him on it. It's the same issue that the Eagles fans are having with him. It's hard to cheer for a piece of shit.

k-diddy